Political embeddedness of the solidarity economy. Between normalization and differentiation in the public sphere

(2026) 6th International Conference on Social Solidarity Economy and the Commons (SSE&Commons 2026) — Location: CEI-Iscte, Lisbon, Portugal (4.November.2026)

Files

2026-11-05 RuizRivera&Lemaitre_SE PolEmbed.pdf
  • Open Access
  • Adobe PDF
  • 750.09 KB

Details

Authors
Abstract
Social and Solidarity Economy (SSE) organizations have been studied primarily as recipients of state support rather than as political actors capable of shaping the institutional environments that govern them. Scholarship has largely focused on what policy does to SSE organizations—how state support shapes, constrains, or transforms their practices, objectives, and governance (Calvo et al., 2019)—while debating their transformative potential against the risks of isomorphic pressure (Enjolras, 2009; Nyssens et al., 2006). Far less attention has been paid to the reverse dynamic: how these organizations act back, collectively and politically, on the institutional environments in which they are embedded (Eynaud et al., 2019). This article addresses that gap by analyzing the spaces of interaction between SSE organizations, notably community-led initiatives, and governmental authorities. Ecuador offers an empirically rich setting. Its 2008 Constitution recognizes the popular and solidarity economy as a constituent sector of the national economy, grounded in reciprocity, solidarity, and Buen Vivir. Additionally, since 2011, this framework has been operationalized through procurement programs in which SSE organizations supply the state on preferential terms. Prior research revealed an institutionalization paradox: policies designed to support alternative economic models inadvertently reproduce the market rationalities they aim to transcend, generating pressures toward technification, professionalization, and bureaucratic formalization that displace reciprocity-based logics (Ruiz‐Rivera & Lemaître, 2026). Taking these findings as its point of departure, this paper shifts from the policy side to the organizational side, asking how organizations respond collectively and politically to such pressures, and what these responses reveal about their democratic function in the public sphere. Theoretically, our analysis draws on Lemaître’s (2009) notion of political embeddedness and on the theory of public action within the solidarity economy tradition (Fraisse, 2017; Giovannini, 2020; Laville, 2005). Methodologically, it relies on organizational ethnographic fieldwork conducted during Ecuador’s SSE institutionalization period (2015–2019). We identified three organizational strategies in the public sphere: (1) adaptation and normalization, through formally constituted representative bodies aligned with governmental priorities; (2) intercooperation as an incipient counter-movement, aimed at reshaping specific procurement instruments from within official consultation spaces; and (3) differentiation through autonomous arenas that maintain critical distance from state-managed spaces. We argue that these strategies reflect distinct modalities of political embeddedness, conditioned by organizational identity, institutional trajectory, and degree of financial dependence on public procurement. The boundary between normalization and transformation is thus negotiated not only within organizations but collectively in the public sphere. Our study contributes to three debates: on the interplay between SSE organizations and the state, on the co-construction of public policy by civil society actors (Dinerstein, 2017; Roka, 2020; Vaillancourt, 2009), and on organizational agency under institutional pressure (Kraatz & Block, 2008). For policy and practice, it clarifies the conditions under which institutionalized participation spaces promote real pluralism and autonomy or risk becoming instruments of instrumentalization and co-optation.
Affiliations

Citations

Ruiz Rivera, M. J., & Lemaître, A. (2026, November 5). Political embeddedness of the solidarity economy. Between normalization and differentiation in the public sphere. 6th International Conference on Social Solidarity Economy and the Commons (SSE&Commons 2026), CEI-Iscte, Lisbon, Portugal. https://hdl.handle.net/2078.5/282434