Charge de la preuve et théorie du contrôle en droit communautaire de la concurrence : pour un changement de perspective

Sibony, Anne-Lise;Barbier de La Serre, Eric
(2007) RTDEur. : revue trimestrielle de droit européen —

Files

ArticlePreuveRTDeur2_2007.pdf
  • Open Access
  • Adobe PDF
  • 501.17 KB

Details

Authors
Abstract
(en) Many authors have pointed to a lack of clarity in the existing case law of EC courts in the field of competition law regarding the allocation of the burden of proof, as well as the determination of the standard of proof. This article attempts to clarify the concepts underlying these questions, bearing in mind that the Court reasons in more than one language. It consists in three sections. The first section is of a theoretical nature. It shows how questions regarding the allocation of the burden of proof and judicial control are conceptualised differently in different legal traditions. It also attempts to clarify the notions of "burden of proof", "standard of proof" and "standard of control". With regard to these notions, as is often the case, EC case law appears to be a melting pot of different legal traditions. It is thus shown that notions originating both in the common law and in the civil law tradition are useful to understand EC case law in relation to the issues of proof and control. The second section is more descriptive. It reviews the current state of the law and illustrates with examples from court cases the usefulness of the various notions defined in the first section. It leads to the conclusion that the common law notions of "standard of proof" and "standard of control" are not sufficient to understand the intensity of control applied by Community courts over Commission’s decisions. The third section proposes another description of judicial control, based on the notions of “scenario” (depicting the economic story line adduced by the Commission to account for anticompetitive effect) and “economic normality”, as perceived by judges.
Affiliations
  • Université de LiègeFaculté de Droit / Institut d’Études Juridiques Européennes (IEJE)

Citations

Sibony, A.-L., & Barbier de La Serre, E. (2007). Charge de la preuve et théorie du contrôle en droit communautaire de la concurrence : pour un changement de perspective. RTDEur. : revue trimestrielle de droit européen. https://hdl.handle.net/2078.5/266304