(en) In this chapter, we seek to rebut the view that clinical legal education has a special relationship with common law. We argue that experiential learning in general and clinical legal education in particular are beneficial in any legal system, including one belonging to the civil law family. We review the theoretical underpinnings of this claim and find that the reasons to favour experiential learning apply to legal education equally in civil and common law systems. We then seek to clarify why experiential learning encounters special resistance in civil law settings. To do this, we go back to 19th century debates about legal education. This allows us to find the seeds of a possible convergence between civil and common law systems when it comes to introducing a measure of experiential learning in legal curricula. We show that giving a greater role to profesionnal-like situations in legal education also in civil law settings would be in line both with elements of the civil law tradition in legal education and with the more contemporary European-wide shift to a skill-based approach in higher education. We do not try to minimise obstacles that stand in the way of this evolution in continental education systems. We distinguish objections from obstacles.
Sibony, A.-L., & Grimes, R. (2018). Experiential learning: Just for ‘common lawyers’ – really? In Grimes Richard, éd. (ed.), Re-thinking Legal Education under the Civil and Common Law: A Roadmap for Constructive Change (p. p. 27-41). Routledge.