Public deliberation, conceptualized as a debate and discussion aimed at producing reasonable, well-informed opinions in which participants are willing to revise preferences in light of discussion, new information, and claims made by fellow participants (Chambers, 2003), has been a bedrock of representative and participative democracy. Learning, defined as an individual and collective process involving the enduring acquisition or modification of cognitive constructs such as beliefs and preferences (Moyson, 2017), is central in such a conceptualization (Gregorcic & Krašovec, 2016). The last years, participatory democracy has been studied and promoted in order to improve the efficacy and legitimacy of policy decisions made through representative democracy, especially at the local level. Despite these developments, representative councils or parliaments remain fundamental to transform the outputs of participatory democracy into concrete decisions. In addition, a better understanding of their deliberations is very instructive for participatory deliberations. Yet, research on public deliberations in representative democracy is rarer. The objective of this paper is twofold. First, we look at the conditions of learning within municipal councils. We do so by presenting the results of a thematic analysis (Paillé & Mucchielli, 2016) of 17 semi-structured interviews with council presidents and administrative directors of municipalities in the Brussels-Capital Region in Belgium. Three categories of conditions are detailed: micro conditions, such as the experience of councilors or their background; meso conditions, such as the communication patterns or informal discussions; and macro conditions, such as the organization of the parties, the deliberative procedures or the publicity of the debates. Second, we present the features of a new software (called e-D&LIB) supposed to foster learning in deliberations based on these results. A set of questions based on the Multiple Streams Framework (Zahariadis, 2019) are asked to the participants about policy problems and solutions. Inspired by the Delphi method (Landetta, 2006), a first round of open questions is combined with a second round of closed questions in order to elicit learning among councilors. In doing so, we contribute to a better understanding of public deliberation and we suggest a new solution to improve it, both in representative and participatory democracy.
Alomar, M. A., Al Saleh, M., & Moyson, S. (2022). A study of learning in Brussels municipal councils and a software to foster it. Participatory Democracy and Digital at Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines. https://hdl.handle.net/2078.5/24569