Files

No attached file found for this publication.

Details

Authors
Abstract
Probation officers (POs) are street-level bureaucrats (Lipsky, 2010) who interact with citizens serving a sentence. Their behavior during supervision has a strong influence on probationers’ odds of recidivism and on the quality of their rehabilitation (Bonta et al., 2008; Kennealy et al., 2012). However, like tax officers (Raaphorst, 2018), POs may be uncertain about probationers’ compliance to policy rules and instructions. In order to deal with such uncertainty, frontline officers’ judgements and decisions can rely on their assessment of the trustworthiness of their citizens-clients (Maynard-Moody & Leyland, 2000). Surprisingly enough, only a handful of public administration studies adopting a street-level perspective have been conducted on officer-offender interactions in probation services (Sabbe et al., 2017). Moreover, there has been no clear attempt to link street-level bureaucracy research with recent developments about official-citizen trust (Moyson et al., 2016; Yang, 2005). To fill these gaps, this paper examines the degree to which POs’ organizational and individual conditions are related to their reliance on trustworthiness assessments when opting for specific uses of discretion: creative discretion (Kelley, 1993) and discretion within the boundaries of the existing rule framework (Hupe, 2013). POs do assess supervisees’ trustworthiness levels based on perceptions of their ability to comply with the rules and to follow the instructions, their integrity in doing so, as well as their benevolence towards probation officers (Mayer & Davis, 1999; Mayer et al., 1995). The test of this hypothesis is based on a survey questionnaire submitted to all Belgian probation officers (N = 473, response rate = 51%). Contrary to what was anticipated, the structural equation modelling of the data demonstrates that the credit POs give to their assessments of probationers’ trustworthiness is loosely related to their organizational and individual conditions. However, the results show that street-level bureaucrats’ personality characteristics appear as an important - but often disregarded - factor to understand frontline decision-making. We conclude with theoretical and practical implications.
Affiliations

Citations

Sabbe, M., Moyson, S., Schiffino-Leclercq, N., & Van de Walle, S. (2019). Dealing with uncertainties during probation work: Trust, but verify? IPPA - ICPP4 - International Public Policy Association, Montréal. https://hdl.handle.net/2078.5/239341