Interacting with Frontline Judges: The Role of Citizens' Emotions in Judicial Decision-Making

(2024) EGPA 2024 CONFERENCE: Strengthening Democratic Governance for Better Public Policies and Services STUDY GROUP XVIII Justice and — Location: Athènes, Grèce (3.September.2024)

Files

No attached file found for this publication.

Details

Authors
Abstract
The relationships between citizens and judges are inherently as unique as they are complex. Far from domination, where judges would merely sanction citizens, these relationships primarily serve a societal function, where judges resolve everyday conflicts (Humbert, 2014). In doing so, frontline judges – i.e., those serving in police courts and peace courts, in Belgium – directly interact face-to-face with multiple citizens on a daily basis, which means that they can be conceptualized as "street-level bureaucrats" (Lipsky, 1980/2010). While frontline judges have been at the center of many studies (e.g., Barral, 2014) – more rarely, with a street-level perspective (e.g., Biland & Steinmetz, 2017) – litigants have remained a blind spot in current academic knowledge so far. Yet, how citizens do (or do not) participate in their interactions with the judges adds to the complexity of their relationships. In addition, this has both important consequences on the result of their interaction and democratic implications on the delivery of this public service. Furthermore, judges, like most civil servants, have traditionally been perceived as neutral and impartial figures, performing their duties without the influence of personal emotions. However, emerging literature underscores the significant impact of emotions in judicial interactions, both from the citizens they engage with and from the judges themselves. Citizens' emotions, which reveal themselves through participation, can have a significant disruptive effect in certain administrative contexts (Dechezelles, 2018), particularly when dealing with frontline bureaucrats (e.g., Eshuis et al., 2023). How do citizens emotions and judges ‘emotions interact at the frontline? To address this question, we draw upon existing research on street-level bureaucracy and on emotions in political science, psychology, sociology, and law to suggest that citizens’ emotional competencies (Mikolajczak et al., 2014) and judges’ empathy to these emotions (Skowronska, 2021) play a crucial role in their interactions, which culminate in judges’ decisions: towards, against, or aways from citizens – in line with Tummers et al. (2015)’s conceptualization. To address our research question, we focus on frontline judges in French-speaking Belgium. Following a “concurrent” research design (Creswell, 2009), we integrate direct observations of court proceedings and semi-structured interviews with both citizens and judges, all analyzed thematically (Paillé & Mucchielli, 2016). The interviews involve the use of a visual grid based on Plutchik's Wheel of Emotions (1980). The preliminary findings suggest that certain emotional competencies, as described by the Salovey and Mayer emotional intelligence model (1990), play a crucial role. In particular, the ability to perceive and evaluate emotions, as well as emotional management, appear to be of particular significance. Citizens who are able to deeply understand the emotional implications of a situation could better regulate their own emotions, and adopt appropriate reactions during their interactions, improving the connection with the judges. In this context, judges' empathy also appears to shape citizens' emotional competencies' impact on administrative decisions: the more judges are likely to feel empathy towards citizens, the more the latter's emotional competencies are likely to have a significant impact, and vice versa. To conclude, we draw the theoretical and practical implications of these results for the management of courts as well as for the procedure and judgements.
Affiliations

Citations

Lequeux, I., Moyson, S., & Schiffino-Leclercq, N. (2024). Interacting with Frontline Judges: The Role of Citizens’ Emotions in Judicial Decision-Making. EGPA 2024 CONFERENCE: Strengthening Democratic Governance for Better Public Policies and Services STUDY GROUP XVIII Justice and, Athènes, Grèce. https://hdl.handle.net/2078.5/234134